Compare / Thumbtack vs Angi
Both sell you leads, but they bill, lock, and share them very differently. Thumbtack floats a pay-per-lead price with no membership; Angi adds a yearly fee, a monthly minimum, and a contract you cannot leave cheaply. Here is the head-to-head, plus the third option neither mentions.
The short answer
Thumbtack fits the contractor who wants no contract and pay-per-lead flexibility to test a market or fill an odd week. Angi fits the crew chasing higher volume that will accept a yearly fee, a roughly $400/mo minimum, and a 12-month lock to get it. Pick Thumbtack for the freedom to walk; pick Angi only if the volume clears your true cost per job. Neither builds a thing you keep, which is why owning your site is the long game.
The advertised per-lead price is the smallest part of this decision. How you are billed, whether you can leave, how many rivals share your lead, and what you own at the end are the lines that separate these three. Every figure below is a real 2026 number.
| Thumbtack | Angi | Your own site | |
|---|---|---|---|
| How you are billed | Pay per lead only; no membership. Charged when you contact a homeowner or they reply to your quote | About $300/yr to join, then per-lead fees, often a monthly minimum near $400 | Starter $500/mo plus a one-time $1,500 setup, or Growth $1,500/mo plus a one-time $500 setup, billed quarterly |
| Per-lead price | Roughly $8-150+ each, moving weekly with demand | Commonly $15-85 each, $100+ in big-ticket trades, on top of membership and minimum | No per-lead fee; the calls the site earns cost nothing extra |
| Contract | None. Turn it on or off whenever you want | Commonly 12 months with auto-renewal; reported penalty of 30-35% of the remaining value to leave early | A quarter at a time, cancel at the end of any quarter |
| Lead sharing | Each project shown to about 4-5 pros; you race to reply | The same lead commonly sold to 3-8 contractors at once | Every call the site produces is yours alone, never shared |
| How the price moves | Floats weekly; a busy season can spike it overnight | Per-lead plus a fixed yearly and monthly floor you pay even in dead weeks | A flat monthly; cost per booked job falls as rankings build |
| Who owns it | Nothing. The profile, reviews and leads belong to Thumbtack | Nothing. The profile, reviews and leads belong to Angi | You own the site, domain, content and reviews from day one |
| When you stop paying | Leads stop the same day | Leads stop, and you may still owe the contract | The site keeps ranking and ringing |
| Best fit | A pro who wants flexibility, no commitment | A crew chasing volume that accepts a lock | A contractor who wants a pipeline they control |
What actually separates them
Thumbtack and Angi both sell a contractor the same thing, access to homeowners who are actively looking, so the choice between them is rarely about the leads themselves. It is about the terms. Thumbtack runs pure pay-per-lead with no annual membership, charging only when you reach out or a homeowner replies, and you can switch it off on a slow week. Angi wraps its leads in a yearly access fee near three hundred dollars, often a monthly minimum around four hundred, and a twelve-month contract that auto-renews. We build and run websites for contractors, so we have a horse in this race, and we will still say when a platform is the right buy: for testing a new service area without signing anything, Thumbtack fits and paying us would be premature. Our argument is only that renting demand forever, on terms the platform sets, loses to owning the channel underneath it in the long run.
The real 2026 numbers
These are current ranges. Your trade, market, and season move them, so treat each as the middle of the road, not a quote.
Thumbtack charges no membership and bills per lead, roughly eight to one hundred fifty dollars or more, only when you contact a homeowner or they answer your quote. The catch is the price moves weekly with supply and demand, so a lead that cost twenty dollars in a slow month can spike during your busy season, exactly when you are least able to babysit it.
Angi commonly charges around three hundred dollars a year to join, then fifteen to eighty-five per lead, over one hundred in big-ticket trades, often with a monthly minimum near four hundred that hits whether the leads were good or not. You usually accept a twelve-month auto-renewing contract to reach that larger marketplace.
Thumbtack shows each project to about four to five pros; Angi commonly sells the same lead to three to eight contractors at once. Neither sends a lead nobody else has. Since roughly seventy-eight percent of homeowners hire whoever answers first, both reward speed over skill, so a slow closer pays for names a faster rival books.
Thumbtack lets you stop any time; there is no contract to escape. Angi commonly locks you for twelve months with auto-renewal and a reported early-termination penalty around thirty to thirty-five percent of the remaining value, plus roughly sixty days notice. That exit is priced so staying feels cheaper than leaving.
The number that decides it
Whichever platform you lean toward, the figure that should drive the decision is your true cost per booked job, and neither company puts it in front of you. Take a real month of total spend, on Thumbtack just lead fees, on Angi the membership share plus the minimum plus every lead, then divide by the jobs you actually signed, not the leads you bought. Reported close rates on shared platforms commonly sit between eight and thirty percent, so two contractors paying the identical per-lead price can land at very different costs per customer purely on how fast and how well they close. Run that number against your profit per job and the comparison settles itself: if a lead becomes a job that nets you well over what you spent, keep buying; if you pay close to your margin per customer, you work for the marketplace, and switching from Angi to Thumbtack only changes which company that is. Renew on this figure, not on a feeling or a sales call.
Pick the right one
Work down this in order and stop at the line that sounds like your business this quarter; the right answer shifts as your calendar grows.
If you want to test a market, run a slow season, or keep zero commitments, Thumbtack wins on flexibility alone: no membership, no contract, off whenever you like. If a yearly fee and a twelve-month lock would keep you up at night, that decides it before you ever compare a single lead price.
Angi's larger marketplace can push more leads your way, which matters when crews are idle and you need jobs this week. But you pay for that volume with a membership, a monthly minimum, and a contract you cannot leave cheaply. Take that trade only if your close rate clears the fixed costs in a quiet month.
Run one real month on whichever you favor and divide total spend by signed jobs, not leads bought. That single number, not the advertised per-lead sticker, is the only fair way to compare Thumbtack to Angi, since their billing shapes are too different to line up otherwise. If you have never run it, you are guessing.
Every dollar on either platform buys one job and disappears. The same money in a site you own buys jobs now and an asset that keeps ranking later. Ask whether, a year from now, you would rather face a renewal notice or hold a website, reviews, and a domain that are yours.
Straight answers
Keep comparing
Your trade
Run the free audit and we send a custom mockup of your rebuild before you commit a cent. You own every asset from day one.